The Roar
The Roar

The Roar

Sam Branigan

Roar Rookie

Joined July 2022

7.8k

Views

25

Published

69

Comments

Published

Comments

Older Submissions

What I’ve found interesting is that the media is desperate for West Coast to trade #1, but why wouldn’t West Coast be considering trading next years 1st round pick for one of North’s picks this year? Would allow them to get Reid and Curtin, whilst also allowing North to select McKercher or Duursma this year plus have two of the first handful of selections next year to continue their rebuild.

AFL Rising Star Power Rankings: Every nominee rated from 1-24 - is it Sheezel's to lose in the best crop of young guns ever?

View Comment
AFL
 
5d

I think you’re rating Nathan Chapman and Brad Nicholson higher than you should, but agree with the broader sentiments – what a list!

AFL Rising Star Power Rankings: Every nominee rated from 1-24 - is it Sheezel's to lose in the best crop of young guns ever?

View Comment
AFL
 
5d

I have a bit of sympathy for Aker in this scenario, as there’s been no accounting for context, and seeing as though his combatant is the AFL’s sacred cow he’s on a hiding to nothing. He’s a bit like Dermie – his mind moves so quickly and his mouth struggles to keep up with it, so what ends up coming out is a bit of a dog’s breakfast. The two points that probably should be emphasised are that he played with a gay player whose company he enjoyed and who he thinks was a great teammate, and a quote he made on Channel 9 back in 2010 when this all kicked off:

“I’m ready. I’m fine with it all”

AFL News: 'Sooked it up' - Aker slams Murphy over 'biased' ABC story, Dons fan favourite bows out

View Comment
AFL
 
2w

I get the feeling, it’s only just a feeling though, that Russell does, in fact, care what Kane has to say!

AFL News: 'Sooked it up' - Aker slams Murphy over 'biased' ABC story, Dons fan favourite bows out

View Comment
AFL
 
2w

Hate to burst your bubble Doc, but the Lions already have this year and both Essendon and Fremantle did last year!

Singin' Elijah's Song: Eagles diamond the Round 22 Rising Star

View Comment
AFL
 
3w

The fear is that in desperation we play a half fit Sam Kerr and all she can do is basically powerwalk around

'He'll look back with regret': Matildas coach admits 'strange' call as hosts on brink of World Cup elimination

View Comment
Football
 
Jul

I think Ashcroft being fourth or fifth banana in the midfield of a top four team isn’t as impressive as what Sheezel has consistently produced in a dreadful team (and that consistency combined with his team being very much off Broadway has made him somewhat forgotten) and Owens has produced playing a very difficult position in a middling team.

Whether injured or not I don’t think Ashcroft deserves to be at the top of the judges scoresheets.

Six Points: Why Ashcroft should still win Rising Star, and a message for Collingwood fans

View Comment
AFL
 
Jul

Agreed – which further emphasises why it is confounding that every club overlooked him multiple times

Overlooked by everyone, but now McVee takes the Round 18 AFL Rising Star nomination

View Comment
AFL
 
Jul

Good as always Tim.

If you’d had room for 7… geez these are troubling times for the Kangaroos. Wardlaw and Sheezel look class, and LDU is quality, but where have their 17th and 18th placed finishes really got them? Their list just seems so bland and so uninteresting, and to be absolutely smoked off the park by a team one spot above them – and who were accused of being an asterisk at the beginning of the season – is damning.

They must be thankful for that pick in the 70s that got them Larkey (which, interestingly, was three selections before the Hawks selected Mitch Lewis – rich pickings indeed!) because otherwise things would be even more dire.

Six Points: Defending Josh Rachele, the Blues' unsung hero, and why the Dogs would be mad to sack Bevo

View Comment
AFL
 
Jul

Has there ever been a bigger team of frauds than the Bulldogs?

Footy Fix: The Swans exposed every one of the Dogs' biggest weaknesses - but did it come too late to save their season?

View Comment
AFL
 
Jul

He’s averaging 12 touches and 1.5 clearances per game – he’s not a natural ball winner

Pedlar to the metal: Crow battler is the Round 16 Rising Star nominee

View Comment
AFL
 
Jul

Definitely tough (very) and skilful, but he still hasn’t shown that ball winning ability of a Danger (or a Roo before that). Plenty of time though!

Pedlar to the metal: Crow battler is the Round 16 Rising Star nominee

View Comment
AFL
 
Jul

Definitely agree – Kangas have the building blocks of a versatile and impressive midfield.

I think lowly teams often improve as the season goes on as, firstly, young players get up to speed with the pace of the game, but also secondly, their coaches adjust game plans and structures to either free things up or tighten things up. Kangas and Hawks both playing with plenty of freedom.

By George the Kangas have a good one here: Wardlaw the Round 13 Rising Star

View Comment
AFL
 
Jun

Indeed – Johnson was excellent last week. He and the Hawks’ Seamus Mitchell should find themselves nominated soonish one would think.

By George the Kangas have a good one here: Wardlaw the Round 13 Rising Star

View Comment
AFL
 
Jun

I think Tim English is like Brodie Grundy was – completely overrated for what he actually does as a ruckman when really he’s a midfielder. Would the Dogs be better off with a competitor in the ruck rather than an extra midfielder?

The Roar's 2023 mid-season AFL All Australian team: Why this underrated Port star should be an AA bolter

View Comment
AFL
 
Jun

Ok, well Suckling didn’t play in the 2013 grand final and didn’t kick any set shot goals in the two other grand finals he played in.

Amiss runs very straight when kicking for goal over short distances.

Nothing Amiss about this nomination: Jye takes out Round 11

View Comment
AFL
 
May

I assume you’re referring to Suckling’s goal in the 2015 Prelim? Compare his approach with that of Amiss when he’s bombed goals from outside 50 on debut and against Geelong a couple of weeks ago – he veers out a long way to get the extra distance (further than Suckling did in the instance I think you’re referring to, but probably not as much as Suckling did normally).

Nothing Amiss about this nomination: Jye takes out Round 11

View Comment
AFL
 
May

No-one dabbles in hindsight bias like an AFL recruiter.

It wasn’t called the ‘Kreuzer Cup’ for nothing. Likewise, players like Marc Murphy, Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio and Cam Rayner were telegrapher out months prior to the draft.

The swapping of bulk picks for one very high pick is also a very, very imperfect science. You might get LDU, Naughton and Fogarty instead of Rayner, but what if it’s Dow, Coffield and Brander?

TOM MORRIS: Harley Reid is a generational talent who could deliver elusive flag to GWS. How ambitious will the Giants be?

View Comment
AFL
 
May

Big issue since Freo came from the clouds and beat them at the MCG last year… have they played well against a good team since?

Six Points: There's one way to stamp out floppers, 2023's dirtiest act, and enjoying the most even season in years

View Comment
AFL
 
May

I was responding to you moaning about the silence being deafening, not about any of the stats you’re doling out

Footy Fix: Mitchell's masterpiece! How 2023's finest coaching performance set up famous Hawthorn win

View Comment
AFL
 
May

Why don’t you stump up and submit an article about them, Don?

Footy Fix: Mitchell's masterpiece! How 2023's finest coaching performance set up famous Hawthorn win

View Comment
AFL
 
May

Nice article Tim, and I certainly appreciate your quite obvious soft spot for the mighty hawks! Reckon you’re a bit harsh on James Blanck though – he can develop into someone who can do a job, and the extra freedom he allows Sicily is obvious.

Footy Fix: Mitchell's masterpiece! How 2023's finest coaching performance set up famous Hawthorn win

View Comment
AFL
 
May

I’m not sure that enough superlatives exist to truly describe the greatness of Jye Amiss.

Weddle for the win: Young Hawk takes out Round 10 Rising Star nomination

View Comment
AFL
 
May

I think we already have the answer given Scrim played at Box Hill over the weekend.

I know there’s been talk of turf toe being managed but he was obviously on the outer over the preseason… I just don’t think Sammy rates him very highly.

Weddle for the win: Young Hawk takes out Round 10 Rising Star nomination

View Comment
AFL
 
May

That basically is my argument Peter… 6.5yrs to go and now they don’t know who will be their coach and how that coach will view the list.

TOM MORRIS: What the Damien Hardwick bombshell means for the AFL coaching landscape

View Comment
AFL
 
May
Older Comments
close